Friday, May 04, 2012

City Hall is "nickel-and-diming residents to death"

Nice turn of phrase by John Cote in the Chronicle this morning aptly describing City Hall's predator/prey relationship with city residents. San Francisco is

a city plagued by complaints that officials are nickel-and-diming residents to death with rising parking ticket fines, putting parking meters in some residential areas and planning to extend meters to Sundays...

Heather Knight's City Insider piece (below in italics) about parking tickets issued in Glen Park quotes MTA spokesman/bullshitter Paul Rose:

"It's business as usual at this point," Rose said. "We're just making sure people follow the rules of the road. The rules are put in place for specific reasons, and in this case, it's to ensure safety for all users."

"Business as usual" means that issuing parking tickets is very profitable for City Hall. As the Transportation Fact Sheet tells us, the city makes twice as much every year from parking tickets ($86,306,584) as it makes on parking meters ($40,520,486).

Paul Rose, spokesman for Muni, said there's been no word from on high that parking enforcement officers are supposed to be raising more money for the cash-strapped agency by issuing such citations. And he said individual officers aren't given a quota for the numbers of tickets issued or paid per citation; rather issuing tickets is up to their own discretion.

Paul Reisman reported on the reality in the Examiner a couple of years ago, when the city laid off some parking control officers to save money. The remaining officers simply picked up the slack to maintain the flow of revenue:

However, the MTA believes there won’t be a revenue drop, so long as the remaining 254 parking control officers step up their production. If each one of those officers gives out 540 monthly citations---nine less than the 2007-08 fiscal year monthly average of 549---the agency won’t lose parking-ticket money.

As the Examiner also reported, all of this nickel-and-diming residents comes as the city is giving adminstrators fat pay hikes.

And the Chronicle's Matier and Ross on overpaid city workers.

Residents along Chenery Street in Glen Park have been perplexed in recent days to learn they live on a hill. Common sense would say the stretch just east of the canyon is flat, but when you're talking about the Municipal Transportation Agency, common sense doesn't always come into play.

Several residents have been shocked to receive numerous citations for $50 apiece for failing to curb their wheels when parked on the street, tickets they've never received before. There's apparently a petition to fight the citations in the works and a pledge by some not to pay up.

Paul Rose, spokesman for Muni, said there's been no word from on high that parking enforcement officers are supposed to be raising more money for the cash-strapped agency by issuing such citations. And he said individual officers aren't given a quota for the numbers of tickets issued or paid per citation; rather issuing tickets is up to their own discretion. He added that citations are actually down year-over-year.

So the most likely scenario is that there's a new officer on patrol along Chenery Street who is taking Muni's rules very, very seriously. After all, the code states that drivers must curb their wheels "on any perceptible grade" which technically is one of at least 3 percent. In hilly San Francisco, that's pretty darn flat.

"It's business as usual at this point," Rose said. "We're just making sure people follow the rules of the road. The rules are put in place for specific reasons, and in this case, it's to ensure safety for all users."
- Heather Knight

Labels: , ,

7 Comments:

At 2:43 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Off Topic - you have rattled on about how Second Street was severed from the bike plan so that we didn't get everything that we want...

http://sf.streetsblog.org/2012/05/04/protected-bike-lanes-ped-safety-top-priorities-for-second-street-neighbors/#more-282530

Safe bike lanes and pedestrian crossings should be top priorities in the redesign of Second Street. That was the major sentiment at a community meeting on Wednesday, where city staffers rebooting the faltered Second Street Improvement Project asked attendees how they would re-envision the corridor.

 
At 2:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

issuing parking tickets is very profitable for City Hall.

Only because parking legally is so hard for City Residents.

 
At 2:53 PM, Blogger Rob Anderson said...

Yes, San Francisco, where all the women are strong, all the men are good-looking, all the children are above average, and all the parking tickets are jusitifed.

 
At 10:35 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The "increase in fines" is actually just passing along the $5 surcharge that the state imposed. But that doesn't fit your narrative.

Also, no ticket is given that isn't deserved. Learn how to park and you won't get a ticket.

 
At 10:53 AM, Blogger Rob Anderson said...

Bullshit. This comment is of course from a bike nut.

 
At 4:21 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Through MMA your kids will get plenty of punch. My main problem by having the DVD was being that it turned out like
looking near a bad formula.

Also visit my blog post - biuro detektywistyczne

 
At 7:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Visitors will discover this short article with searching
records that could many other individuals have passed away of the
ideas with different models and brands. In comparison, a small number of
machines will set you back even less as they're of great importance and downward speed up and likewise have exactly the simple duties. It is really both speed to improved manipulate precise throughout nighttime. Remember, while embed in the juicer as well drink up. The site for no reason unpleasant you'll more than
you are able roughly a tool occur looking at prior
to your get the house.

Also visit my web site best blender reviews

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home