Friday, December 17, 2010

People of Aghanistan: 68% support US presence

The story below is from ABC News:

Views Improve Sharply in Afghanistan, Though Criticisms of the U.S. Stay High

Hopes for a brighter future have soared in Afghanistan, bolstered by a broad rally in support for the country’s re-elected president, improved development efforts and economic gains. Blame on the United States and NATO for violence has eased---but their overall ratings remain weak. In one key shift, the latest poll by ABC News, the BBC and ARD German TV finds that sharply more Afghans now see the Taliban as the main source of their country’s strife, while many fewer blame the United States or its allies---significant progress in a central aim of the new commander of U.S. and NATO forces, Gen. Stanley McChrystal...

BOTTOM LINES: Fundamentally, just 38 percent rate the work of the United States in Afghanistan positively---up 6 points in the past year, but far below its peak, 68 percent in 2005. (NATO’s ratings are as low, and flat.) Fifty-one percent have a favorable view of the United States overall---vastly below its high point, 83 percent, in 2005. And U.S. favorability drops to 35 percent in the East and 29 percent in the South (vs. 59 percent in the rest of the country)---again, plummeting where the United States is most actively engaged in combat.

While its performance is rated poorly, most Afghans nonetheless see a need for the United States’ presence in Afghanistan---a view probably informed by very broad rejection of the likely alternative, the Taliban. As noted, more than two-thirds of Afghans support the presence of U.S. forces in their country, slightly up from last year although still below its peak. (Most Afghans last year opposed a troop increase in the abstract; the shift from those views to support for Obama’s surge is mirrored in U.S. public opinion as well.)

Support for the planned increase in U.S. and NATO forces is accompanied by majority belief the United States will accomplish the goals set out by Obama---for example, training Afghan forces to take over security, strengthening the Kabul government, preventing the Taliban from retaking control, preventing al Qaeda from re-establishing a base of operation and reducing corruption. But fewer, ranging from 22 to 33 percent, are “very” confident these will happen.

The commitment expressed by the planned surge may be another factor bolstering public hopes. There are, in any case, other signs of improved views of the West: There’s been a 14-point gain from last year, to 83 percent, in the view among Afghans that it was right for the United States to invade and overthrow the Taliban just more than eight years ago. And the number of Afghans who say attacking Western forces can be justified has dropped sharply, from 25 percent a year ago to 8 percent, a new low. (It jumps to 22 percent in the South---but that’s half of what it was there a year ago.)...

See also a public opinion poll of the people of Afganistan by the Asia Foundation.



At 9:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Any anti-american Afghani worth his salt would be in favor of the occupation. It is contributing to the economic downfall of the US. QED.

At 9:00 AM, Blogger Rob Anderson said...

Bullshit. Just wishful thinking by an anti-American American. Besides, the story is about Aghanis who support the US effort. What about them?

At 11:28 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Right. If I am in the Taliban, and they ask me if I support the US being in Afghanistan, I would enthusiastically say *YES*

The US has dumped a trillion plus dollars into Iraq and Afghanistan. That's more economic impact on the US than 9/11 itself.

The US has 10,000 casualties there. More than 9/11 itself.

Even if many Afghanis detest the Taliban, it's not the "average" that is important. It only took 10 radicals to take down the WTC towers. Maybe 100 if you count logistics. Our presence there increases the radical fringe that is the real problem.

A trillion dollars spent on Cancer treatment and research would save more American lives than this war. It's not even close. But apparently that would be "anti-American" to cure Americans suffering from cancer.

At 12:20 PM, Blogger Rob Anderson said...

Iraq and Afghanistan are two different countries and two different wars. Afghanistan is where the 9/11 attackers were trained and where Osama Bin Psycho was based before 9/11. The idea that we should allow those folks to retake Afghanistan so they can begin plotting against us again is unacceptable.

As this poll shows, the people of Afghanistan oppose allowing the Taliban to control their country. Abandoning those people to the religious fanatics would be both immoral and contrary to our national interests.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home