Saturday, December 09, 2017

Riding a bike can never be safe

Cycling can be made safer but never safe enough for me and most people. 

Yes, the most serious threat for cyclists are accidents with motor vehicles, which can mean death and serious injury.

But experts on cycling tell us that most cycling accidents are "solo falls" that don't involve motor vehicles. Bike messenger/author Robert Hurst:

Realistically, it is not the prospect of dying in an accident, but that of being sent to the hospital with a serious injury, that hangs over the vulnerable heads of cyclists. The cyclist’s primary goal should be, first and foremost, to avoid serious injury. This is the cyclist’s bottom line. We must do whatever it takes to achieve this goal, short of staying at home (page 70, The Art of Cycling).

Hurst and many reality-based cyclists think the risk is worth it. The rest of us think that if what you're doing includes the risk of serious injury you should stop doing it. Do something else to get around when you leave home.

These thoughts are prompted by still another horror story by a cyclist (Is Road Riding Worth the Risk?):

The impact was as sudden and unexpected as lightning on a cloudless afternoon. One moment I was pedaling on a side road to my house after wrapping up a trail ride. The next I was 20 feet off the road on my back, tangled beneath my mountain bike in a stand of chamisa. People talk about their lives flashing before them in such moments, but for me there was only the sound of breaking glass and a searing pain in my left side as the car hit me from behind.

The writer on the increasing threat of distracted driving:

It seems like I hear a story of a cyclist getting hit by a car almost daily. Between 2010 and 2016, fatalities of cyclists struck by vehicles rose by 35 percent, up to 840, in 2016. People for Bikes says that increase doesn’t indicate a growing risk, but rather the overall growth of cycling. Yet, cyclists notwithstanding, fatal automobile accidents due to distracted driving have also ballooned during that same period. 

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration estimates that on any given day during daylight hours, some 660,000 people are using cell phones while they drive. In the past few years, I’ve told my wife, Jen, that as many people as I see texting while driving, it seems almost inevitable that I’d eventually get hit...

Yes, take up mountain biking or bike where there's no or little traffic. Best of all, don't ride a bike at all.

In that widely ignored UC study on cycling accidents in San Francisco, solo falls--called "cyclist-only" accidents in the study---were often just as serious as accidents with motor vehicles:

In our comparison of AVB[auto-versus-bicycle] and CO[cyclist-only] injuries, we found that CO injuries four times more likely to be admitted to the hospital after presentation in the emergency department. Despite this increased likelihood of admission, our data indicated that length of hospital stay, hospital disposition, and the Mean Injury Severity Scores were not different among AVB injury patients and CO injury patients.

Even so City Hall urges the city's children to ride bikes to school!


Labels: , , , , ,

4 Comments:

At 7:23 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Scientist have proven that bicycles are inherently unsafe - evidence here: https://www.google.com/search?q=bicycles+are+inherently+unsafe&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8

 
At 5:12 PM, Anonymous Gregski said...

Dear Rob, As I've written before, I am an 8,000mi/yr cyclist (3500mi in San Francisco alone) who recognizes and accepts the risks of what I do. I totally respect and honor those who choose other, lawful means of conveying themselves around town. I feel sorry for them as their city hall keeps trying to socially engineer them into bicycling by screwing up the streets. But only a little, seeing how they keep re-electing the petty tyrants who are doing this to them.

I find what you wrote in this post to be very agreeable with one exception. I am very skeptical that collisions with motor vehicles are the biggest risk we cyclists face. As awful as the distracted driving is nowadays, it is very predictable and can be dealt with effectively by attentive cyclists. It's human-powered traffic that terrifies me the most. Especially gadget-distracted pedestrians jumping out from between cars into traffic. My personal record of crashes also supports the UC study: many more solo falls than traffic collisions.

 
At 2:42 PM, Blogger Rob Anderson said...

Anonymous:
Your link leads to other pro-bike links.

I can provide more convincing links about bike safety: here, here, here, here, here, and here.

 
At 2:47 PM, Blogger Rob Anderson said...

A functional link to the American Association of Neurological Surgeons on head injuries.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home