Bike people oppose Whole Foods in the Haight
On Thursday October 23 the Planning Commission will hear the proposal to put a Whole Foods Market at the old Cala Foods site at Haight and Stanyan. The main opposition is coming from the Haight Ashbury Neighborhood Council (HANC) and anti-car bike people, like Rob Bregoff. In a PROSF message last Friday, Bregoff made his bias clear:
“Ample Parking” is far too much. This is on a major bus corridor, and if you’ve stood on the curb in front of the WF on California and Franklin, you can see how much drivers jockeying for parking can tie up traffic. What ever happened to our anti-formula retail legislation? WF will take local dollars and send them back to their HQ in TEXAS! I share the concern for the blight at Haight/Stanyan, and I think that housing over retail is a good thing, but this is bad retail. I’m sure that the Brennans would have no problem renting out storefronts in a building in that location, and since it’s on a transit-rich corner, with neighborhood support, the parking requirements could be waved[sic] for the residential units. More parking = more traffic. Always.
Actually one can more convincingly argue the opposite, that inadequate parking is what creates more traffic. Take, for example, the supermarket where I often shop, the Lucky Market at Masonic and Fulton, which has 251 parking spaces in the parking lot beneath the store. Even though the store does a brisk business, you never see a traffic jam at the only entrance to the garage on Fulton Street, which also carries the #5 Fulton Muni line. Since the Whole Foods market proposed for Haight/Stanyan is a much smaller operation, it's only asking for 114 parking spaces for market customers, 62 spaces for the new housing units, and even 47 spaces for bikes!
Bregoff cites the Whole Foods at California and Franklin as a cautionary traffic tale, but the problem there is inadequate parking, not too much---or "ample"---parking, since it has only 90 parking spaces. Ditto for the Trader Joes at Geary and Masonic: their parking lot is way too small---a mere 61 spaces---which is why cars have to line up on Masonic to get access to the lot as people leave.
The moral of the story: "ample"/adequate parking is the way to avoid traffic problems in the neighborhood. But Bregoff and the bike people will be out in force to try to convince the Planning Commission that an underground parking lot on the site is going to be a problem for the neighborhood. The rest of us---the reality-based community, including all those in the Haight-Ashbury desperate to have a supermarket again---also need to be there to counter the anti-car bike people who will try to sab the project.
More on Bregoff by clicking on "Rob Bregoff" at the end of this post.
To all -
After nearly three years of working our way through the maze of City Planning, I am happy to announce that the 690 Stanyan Street project will have a hearing at the San Francisco Planning Commission on October 23, 2008!
On behalf of 690 Stanyan Street LLC, I would like to thank all of you who have supported this project, who have visited our website (www.690stanyan.com), have written letters of support to the Planning Department and those who testified in front of the Planning Commission for the Draft Environmental Impact Report last February.
Although the level of public support on record with the City is nearing 10:1, the battle has not been won yet. Please plan on attending the Planning Commission hearing on October 23, 2008 if you can, or else please submit a further letter of support. Tell the Commissioners that you want the former Cala Foods eyesore remedied, that you want a clean, well-used corner, you want a Whole Foods Market, that indeed this area deserves a world class, full service grocery store, that you want good-quality new housing in the neighborhood . Most importantly, that you want your voices of sanity heard above the City's usual din of professional nay-sayers . It is time to abandon the past and to move forward on this very important project. We believe that the fate of this project at the Commission will rest with the level of support or objection perceived by most of the Planning Commissioners.
Information regarding the hearing:
The Planning Commission will hold a Public Hearing to decide whether to approve the project or not on Thursday, October 23, 2008, beginning at 1:30 p.m. or later (please call 558-6422 on or after Monday, October 20, 2008 for a recorded message giving a more precise hour that the hearing on this specific matter will begin), in City Hall, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlette Place, Room 400.
The City Planner for this case is Jonas Ionin : please contact him at (415) 558-6309 or email@example.com for more information about the project, referencing Case No. 2006.0460C.
If you are unable to attend this very important hearing, you may submit written comments by mail, FAX or email (these need to be sent by October 22, 2008, in order to be included in the official record). Please address these to:
SF Planning Department
1650 Mission Street, Suite 400
San Francisco, CA 94103
firstname.lastname@example.org (if you send an email, please also cc : email@example.com )
or to the commission secretary at FAX (415) 558-6409
Again, thank you for your consideration, your support, and most of all, your patience! Please do refer back to www.690stanyan.com for more information about the calendar and when the item may be heard.
Mark J. Brennan, 690 Stanyan Street, LLC